Winter has gripped North India, and amid the hazy, chilly mornings and evenings, a hot water shower refreshes both our mind and soul. When we think of a warm, cosy bath, the first thing that comes to mind is a water heater. One of the most common decisions we face when buying a new water heater is whether to choose an instant water heater or a storage water heater.
While, many of us do know the properties and usage of the two, for those who are still wondering what a storage and instant water heater is, here is this detailed guide to help you choose the right one as per your usage.
In a nutshell, instant water heaters are for those who need hot water as per their demand. These geysers need limited space and hence are ideal for people who have small bathrooms.
Meanwhile, storage water heaters are ideal for individuals who require constant hot water.
Also Read: AO smith water geyser: 10 Best picks for your home
Let us dive into detail:
What are instant water heaters?
Instant water heaters, also called tankless or on-demand water heaters, provide hot water immediately without storing it. When you turn on the tap, cold water flows through the heater, where it’s rapidly warmed using electric coils or gas burners.
These heaters are compact, energy-efficient, and ideal for small spaces or specific outlets. Imagine washing your hands or taking a shower with uninterrupted hot water, no matter the time! They’re perfect for modern households seeking convenience.
Top Instant water heaters for you:
Pros and cons of Instant water heater:
| Aspect | Pros | Cons |
| Energy Efficiency | – Uses energy only when hot water is needed, reducing energy bills by 24-34%. |
– May require higher initial electrical or gas infrastructure investments. |
| Compact Design | – Small and space-saving; ideal for tight spaces. |
– Limited to serving one or two fixtures simultaneously in some models. |
| Hot Water Supply | – Provides continuous hot water; no need to wait for a tank to refill. |
– Flow rate limitations; may struggle during peak demand. |
| Durability | – Long lifespan (15-20 years, often longer than traditional tanks). |
– Requires regular maintenance to prevent scaling or mineral build-up. |
| Environmental Impact | – Reduces energy waste and greenhouse gas emissions. |
– May require more resources for installation, especially in older homes. |
| Temperature Control | – Provides consistent temperature without fluctuations caused by stored water cooling down. |
– Risk of inconsistent temperature if the demand exceeds its capacity. |
| Safety | – Lower risk of tank leakage or catastrophic failures. |
– Requires careful setting adjustments to avoid overly hot water due to instant heating. |
Also Read: How to increase the lifespan of your water heater?
What are storage heaters?
Storage water heaters are tanks that heat and store water for use in homes or businesses. They typically have an insulated tank ranging from 20 to 80 gallons, maintaining a set temperature using a thermostat.
When hot water is used, cold water refills the tank, and the heating process starts again. Powered by electricity, gas, or propane, they are commonly found in basements or utility closets. While reliable, they can lose heat over time (standby heat loss) and may take time to reheat if fully depleted.
Top Storage water heaters for you:
Pros and cons of Storage water heater:
| Aspect | Pros | Cons |
| Cost | – Generally less expensive upfront compared to tankless models. |
– Higher operational costs due to standby heat loss (energy is used to maintain stored water temperature). |
| Installation | – Easier and less expensive to install, especially as a replacement. |
– Requires adequate space for the tank, which may be limited in smaller homes. |
| Hot Water Supply | – Provides a steady supply of hot water (depends on tank size, typically 30-80 gallons). |
– Hot water can run out, requiring a wait for reheating. |
| Efficiency | – Can use insulation to improve efficiency and reduce standby heat loss. |
– Lower energy efficiency compared to tankless models. |
| Maintenance | – Straightforward maintenance, including periodic flushing to reduce sediment buildup. |
– Risk of tank corrosion or leaks, requiring replacement every 8-12 years (on average). |
| Versatility | – Suitable for areas with inconsistent water pressure or electric supply. |
– Less energy-efficient in long-term use compared to modern tankless systems. |
| Recovery Rate | – Quick recovery rates for smaller tanks. |
– Recovery times can be slower for larger households or high-demand situations. |
| Durability | – Simple technology with proven reliability. |
– Lifespan is shorter (typically 10-15 years) compared to tankless options (20+ years). |
Also Read: Best 5-star geysers for home: Choose from top 10 instant water heaters of different capacities
Key difference between Instant and Storage water heaters:
Heating mechanism:
An instant water heater heats water on demand using high-powered heating elements, providing hot water immediately when needed. Conversely, a storage water heater uses a tank to store and maintain a constant supply of pre-heated water, heated slowly by a thermostat-regulated element. Instant heaters activate only when water is drawn, while storage models continuously heat water to keep it at the desired temperature. This fundamental difference makes instant heaters suitable for small, immediate needs, while storage heaters are better for sustained or simultaneous use by multiple outlets, as they rely on a reserve of already-heated water.
Energy Efficiency:
Instant water heaters are generally more energy-efficient as they heat water only when required, avoiding standby heat loss associated with continuously maintaining a tank of hot water. In contrast, storage water heaters experience energy loss over time due to heat dissipation, even when not in active use. However, for households with high water usage, storage models may sometimes operate more efficiently by heating larger volumes at lower power levels. Still, instant heaters often align better with energy-saving goals, especially for smaller households or intermittent usage scenarios, where waste from idle heating is significantly reduced.
Capacity and storage:
Instant water heaters lack a storage tank, offering water on demand without limits, but may struggle to support multiple outlets simultaneously. Storage water heaters include a tank (typically 20-80 gallons) to store pre-heated water, ensuring availability even during high usage. While storage heaters are better suited for larger households or extensive hot water needs, they require time to refill and reheat if the tank is depleted. Instant heaters are ideal for smaller applications, like a single shower, but may not sustain prolonged or simultaneous usage effectively without advanced models designed for high flow rates.
Water heating time:
Instant water heaters deliver hot water immediately as cold water flows through the heating element, eliminating any waiting period. Storage water heaters, however, require time to heat the water in the tank to the set temperature before use. Reheating a depleted tank can take anywhere from 30 minutes to over an hour, depending on the tank size and heater capacity. For situations requiring rapid access to hot water, instant heaters outperform storage models, making them more convenient for busy users or those who need quick, intermittent bursts of hot water.
Durability:
Instant water heaters generally have longer lifespans, averaging 20 years, as they face less exposure to constant heating and water storage conditions that can cause corrosion or mineral build-up. Storage water heaters typically last 10–15 years due to wear on the tank from continuous heating and potential issues like rust or sediment accumulation. Proper maintenance, such as flushing the tank and replacing the anode rod, can extend a storage heater’s life. Instant heaters, with fewer moving parts and no tank, are less susceptible to damage, offering durability and reliability over time.
Space-saving and installation
Instant water heaters are compact and wall-mounted, making them ideal for small spaces or areas with limited installation flexibility. Their lightweight design allows for easy integration into bathrooms, kitchens, or utility closets. In contrast, storage water heaters require significant space for the tank, which can be bulky and limit placement options. Installation for storage heaters often involves more complex piping and ventilation, while instant heaters typically have a simpler setup. For modern apartments or minimalistic setups, instant heaters provide a clear advantage, while storage models are better suited for larger homes with adequate installation space.
Cost
Storage water heaters are typically more affordable upfront, including both the unit price and installation costs, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious buyers. However, they incur higher operational costs over time due to energy losses from maintaining a heated tank. Instant water heaters are costlier initially and may require additional electrical or gas upgrades, but their energy efficiency can lead to long-term savings. The choice depends on balancing upfront costs with operational efficiency, household needs, and water usage patterns. Long-term users often find the higher investment in instant heaters worthwhile for energy and space savings.
Also Read: The eco debate: Is your water heater environmentally friendly?
Conclusion: Which one is better?
Instant water heater is ideal for small families or in houses with limited capacity due to its compact size and lower upfront cost. Whereas, people staying in large families may benefit from a storage water heater as it can store and give hot water to more people in frequent demands.
So, ideally, your choice between an instant and storage water heater depends upon your usage and the size of the family.
Similar articles for you:
Best price for Bajaj 25 litre geyser: Elevate your bathing experience
Crompton geyser vs other brands: 10 advanced geyser models to pick from
Havells geyser 25 litre price: Bring home best model, here are top 10 choices
Best geyser for home: Explore top 10 models for this winter
FAQ for instant vs storage heaters
- What size water heater do I need for my household?
The size of water heater you need depends on the size of your household and your water usage habits. For Tank Water Heaters: A 30-40 gallon tank is usually enough for 1-2 people, a 40-50 gallon tank works for 3-4 people, and larger households might need a 50-80 gallon tank. For Tankless Water Heaters: Instead of gallons, you’ll need to consider flow rate (measured in gallons per minute) and temperature rise. Most households need a tankless unit with a flow rate of 5-10 GPM to supply hot water to multiple sources, like showers and faucets, simultaneously.
- What is the difference between instant and storage water heaters?
Instant heaters provide hot water on demand and usually have small capacities, while storage heaters store and maintain a large amount of hot water for extended use.
- How does tank material impact the water heater’s lifespan?
Corrosion-resistant materials like glass-lined or enamel-coated tanks extend the heater’s durability by preventing rust and corrosion.
- What is the ideal tank capacity for a family of four?
The tank capacity of 15–25 litres is generally sufficient for a family of four.
Disclaimer: At Hindustan Times, we help you stay up-to-date with the latest trends and products. Hindustan Times has an affiliate partnership, so we may get a part of the revenue when you make a purchase. We shall not be liable for any claim under applicable laws, including but not limited to the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, with respect to the products. The products listed in this article are in no particular order of priority.